The Seller Backed Out. We Can Force the Sale.

Money isn't always the remedy you want. When a seller walks away from a signed real estate contract, New York law may allow you to compel them to complete the transaction at the agreed-upon price — not just recover your deposit. We help buyers and sellers pursue specific performance claims in New York courts when a contract breach can't be made right with money alone.

Automatic Stay Takes Effect the Day You File   •   Most Cases Discharged in 90 days in the EDNY, SDNY and New Jersey   •   Home Equity Up to $204,825 Protected for Nassau and Suffolk County Residents   •   Credit Cards, Medical Bills, Personal Loans, Most Judgments Dischargeable and more   •   Bankruptcy, Wage Garnishment, and Student Loans Resolved Together

What the Florida Divorce Process Looks Like

Understanding how agreement—or conflict—shapes the process.

What Chapter 7 Cannot Discharge

Why Specific Performance Exists in Real Estate Law

Real estate is treated differently under the law because no two properties are identical. A court can't simply order a seller to pay damages and call it fair — you wanted that house, in that location, at that price. Because each parcel of real property is considered legally unique, New York courts recognize that monetary compensation may not adequately remedy a breach. Specific performance is the legal doctrine that fills that gap, allowing a court to order a party to fulfill their contractual obligations rather than simply pay for walking away.

 

When a seller accepts your offer, signs a purchase contract, and then refuses to close — whether because they found a higher offer, changed their mind, or decided to stay — that is a breach of contract. Your remedy isn't limited to getting your earnest money back. As the non-breaching buyer, you may have the right to petition a court to compel the sale and take title to the property on the terms you already agreed to.

When New York Courts Will Grant Specific Performance

Not every breach of a real estate contract leads to a successful specific performance claim. Courts apply a defined set of criteria before ordering a party to complete a transaction. Understanding those criteria is the first step in evaluating whether you have a viable claim.

 

For a court to grant specific performance in a New York real estate dispute, the following conditions generally must be met:

 

  • A valid, enforceable contract exists between the parties
  • The contract meets all formation requirements, including proper signatures and consideration
  • The property at issue is unique — which, in real estate, is presumed by law
  • The buyer was ready, willing, and able to perform at the time of the breach
  • Money damages would not adequately compensate the non-breaching party
  • The party seeking relief has not materially breached the contract themselves

 

When these elements are present, New York courts have the authority to order the seller to complete the sale. We evaluate each of these factors at the outset of every specific performance case.

What the Specific Performance Process Looks Like

Pursuing specific performance is a form of real estate litigation. It begins with filing a complaint in New York Supreme Court and moves through the discovery and motion practice phases before reaching resolution — either through a court order, a negotiated settlement, or a trial. The timeline varies depending on the complexity of the dispute and how aggressively the other side contests the claim.

 

Throughout the process, we work to build the evidentiary record that supports your claim: the executed contract, proof of your financing or funds, documentation of the breach, and any communications that establish the seller's intent to walk away. Courts in New York take these cases seriously when the record is well-developed. Our job is to make sure yours is.

Situations We Handle in Specific Performance Cases

Seller Refuses to Close After Signing

The most common scenario: a seller accepts your offer, the contract is executed, and then they refuse to appear at closing or formally withdraw. This is a clear breach, and it is precisely the situation specific performance was designed to address. We move quickly to document the breach and file for relief before the seller can complicate the property's title or transfer it to another buyer.

Seller Accepted a Higher Offer After Contracting with You

If a seller accepted a better offer after already signing a contract with you, they have breached their agreement. The fact that a more attractive offer came along does not excuse the breach or entitle the seller to walk away from an enforceable contract. We pursue specific performance in these situations to hold the seller to the deal they already made.

Seller Claims the Contract Is Unenforceable

A common defense in specific performance litigation is that the contract itself is invalid — due to a missing signature, a defective contingency clause, or some other alleged formation defect. We examine the contract closely before filing and address any vulnerabilities in the record before the other side can exploit them. When the contract is sound, we defend its enforceability aggressively.

Business couple reviewing real estate documents with house and office building in background, keys and contract visible
Brass balance scale with two pans on a central stand, one pan hanging higher than the other.

Why Buyers Choose Aronow Law for Specific Performance Claims

We have been handling real estate disputes in New York for more than 23 years. Specific performance cases require an attorney who understands both contract law and real estate litigation — and who is prepared to take the case through court if the seller won't come to the table. That is what we do.

 

When you call us, you speak with an attorney directly. There is no intake screener, no 10-minute cap on your consultation, and no waiting for a callback from someone who doesn't know your file. We offer free consultations with no time limit, because understanding your situation fully is the only way to give you an honest assessment of your claim. We also serve Spanish-speaking clients throughout the entire legal process — not just at intake.

Frequently Asked Questions About Specific Performance in New York

  • Can I force a seller to sell me a house in New York if they backed out of a signed contract?

    Yes, in many cases. New York courts can order specific performance in real estate disputes, compelling a seller to complete a sale at the agreed-upon price. You must demonstrate that a valid contract existed, that you were ready and able to perform, and that money damages are not an adequate substitute for the property itself.

  • How long does a specific performance lawsuit take in New York?

    The timeline depends on the complexity of the dispute and whether the seller contests the claim. Cases that settle early through negotiation can resolve in a few months. Contested matters that proceed through motion practice and trial can take a year or longer. We assess the facts of your situation and give you a realistic timeline at the outset.

  • What if the seller already sold the property to someone else after backing out of my contract?

    This is a more complicated situation, but it does not necessarily end your claim. If the subsequent buyer had notice of your contract, the court may still be able to unwind the sale. Even where that is not possible, you may have a strong damages claim against the seller. We analyze the sequence of events and advise you on the best available remedy.

  • Does specific performance work for sellers too, or only buyers?

    Specific performance is available to both parties. If a buyer signs a contract and then refuses to close without legal justification, the seller may be able to compel the buyer to complete the purchase. The same legal standards apply — the contract must be valid and enforceable, and the party seeking relief must have been ready and able to perform.

  • What is the difference between a specific performance claim and a contract dispute?

    A contract dispute is the broader category — it covers any disagreement about the terms, validity, or performance of a contract. Specific performance is a specific remedy within that category, one that asks the court to order a party to fulfill their contractual obligations rather than pay money damages. Many specific performance cases also involve contract disputes over what the agreement required in the first place.

Ready to Pursue the Property You Were Promised?

If a seller has backed out of a signed contract and you want the house — not just your deposit — we are ready to help you understand your options. Specific performance is a powerful remedy when the facts support it, and we have the experience to evaluate your claim honestly and pursue it effectively. Contact Aronow Law today for a free consultation with no time limit.